Skip to navigation Skip to content
mpc journal

Towards Equality and Diversity

  • News
  • Political Analysis
    • Levant & Mesopotamia
      • Iraq
      • Israel/Palestine
      • Jordan
      • Lebanon
      • Syria
    • North Africa
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
    • Arabian Peninsula
      • Bahrain
      • Kuwait
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • UAE
      • Yemen
    • Turkey & Iran
    • Mashreq–Worldwide Relations
    • Analysing the Mashreq
  • Culture +
    • Intercultural
    • Diversity
    • Art +
    • Music
    • Fashion
    • History +
    • Religion +
    • Society
  • Social Minorities +
    • Atheists +
    • LGBT +
    • Non-Arab +
    • Non-Muslim +
    • Campaigns
  • About us
    • Philosophy
    • Terms of Use
    • MPC Journal Guidelines
    • Monthly Issues
    • Books
    • Online Training for Journalistic Writing
  • Contact us
    • Submit an Article
    • MPC Journal Team
    • Contributors on MPC Journal
    • Vacancies
  • العربية
mpc journal
  • MPC Journal Guidelines
  • Terms of Use
mpc journal

Towards Equality and Diversity

  • News
  • Political Analysis
    • Levant & Mesopotamia
      • Iraq
      • Israel/Palestine
      • Jordan
      • Lebanon
      • Syria
    • North Africa
      • Algeria
      • Egypt
      • Libya
      • Morocco
      • Tunisia
    • Arabian Peninsula
      • Bahrain
      • Kuwait
      • Qatar
      • Saudi Arabia
      • UAE
      • Yemen
    • Turkey & Iran
    • Mashreq–Worldwide Relations
    • Analysing the Mashreq
  • Culture +
    • Intercultural
    • Diversity
    • Art +
    • Music
    • Fashion
    • History +
    • Religion +
    • Society
  • Social Minorities +
    • Atheists +
    • LGBT +
    • Non-Arab +
    • Non-Muslim +
    • Campaigns
  • About us
    • Philosophy
    • Terms of Use
    • MPC Journal Guidelines
    • Monthly Issues
    • Books
    • Online Training for Journalistic Writing
  • Contact us
    • Submit an Article
    • MPC Journal Team
    • Contributors on MPC Journal
    • Vacancies
  • العربية
LGBT+Social MinoritiesSociety

Why Does Gay Sex Scare Modern Muslims? It Didn’t in the Golden Age

April 18, 20161789 Maajid Nawaz
GaySyrianRefugeesDresden0051444907586 - Why Does Gay Sex Scare Modern Muslims? It Didn’t in the Golden Age - MPC Journal
Four young refugees in their apartment in the German city of Dresden. They were taken out of official refugee shelters after being harassed – © Photo: Mario Wezel for The Washington Post
Colonialism taught Muslims to be ashamed of many things, including sexual orientation. Now they are more intolerant (and maybe more hypocritical) than the Victorians.

LONDON — Half of British Muslims say being gay “should be outlawed.” Thus ran the headline in London’s Sunday Times this week. Even more opposed gay marriage, while almost half thought it was unacceptable for a gay or lesbian to teach their children.

These findings from an ICM poll will be presented in a Channel 4 documentary: What British Muslims Really Think, airing this Wednesday. The show will portray the growing divergence between mainstream Britain and its Muslim communities.

Poll after poll of British Muslims has revealed statistically significant levels of illiberal opinion. Polling methodology and data may contain errors, as some critics note, but this is only scientifically rectified by more data, not by defensive posturing. A 2009 poll by Gallup found that zero per cent of Britain’s Muslims believed homosexual acts to be morally acceptable. What previous polls have shown us time and again is more of the same. This latest ICM poll asked a slightly different question, about whether homosexual acts should be legal rather than viewed as morally acceptable. Despite half saying no, this time 18 per cent did say being gay should remain legal. Progress? Well if our baseline was zero, there could only ever be progress.

Such numbers ought to prompt an urgent conversation about why Europe is having trouble integrating its Muslim communities. And it is likely that the answer, in part, relates to rising neo-fundamentalist approaches to scripture among Muslims.

There was a time when it was not like this.

Traditionally, Islam was open to exploring beauty and sexuality, especially when Islamic culture flourished and Europe was in what were known as the Dark Ages. The Prophet Muhammad taught that “God is Beautiful, and loves Beauty.” The 11th century Andalusian scholar Ibn Hazm wrote “The Ring of the Dove,” a treatise on the different stages of love, including some rather explicit real-life stories.

It is true that many early Muslim scholars condemned homosexuality, and cited scripture to justify their position. But the themes of love and sexuality have been debated and discussed by Muslim theologians and artists for centuries. The word “homosexuality” is not even used in the Quran. In fact, it did not exist in the Arabic language. The modern Muslim conclusion that homosexuality is “unnatural” is therefore not based on anything in scripture.

The Quranic story of the prophet Lot is often invoked by religious-conservative Muslims to denounce homosexuals. But even here, there has been debate. A renowned traditional authority on the Quran, Al-Kisa’i Al-Kufi, took the view that the story of Lot referred to heterosexual men who raped other men.

The chapter of Al-Nur (Quran 24:31) specifically recognizes “men who are not in need of women.” As the context of the passage shows, these are men who are not attracted to women. They may have been gay or asexual, but, by definition, they were not heterosexual men. They are also not judged or condemned anywhere in the Quran. The Prophet’s own example shows that he accepted men living around him who were called “Mukhannath,” seen to be “acting like women.”

This subtle early recognition grew to a point where it was open within the courts of various caliphs in the Muslim Golden Age. Abu Nuwas (756-814) was one of the greatest classical Arab poets. He flourished during the start of the Abbasid era Golden Age (750-1258) based in Baghdad.

As was normal during this period, sexual roles were only imagined in terms of active and passive participants, not as gay or straight sex, and what we would today describe as homosexuality was clear and present in this society.

Biographies of the bohemian Abu Nuwas recount his many sexual relationships with women and teenage boys, especially under the patronage of Caliph Al-Amin (809-13), with whom Abu Nuwas shared many experiences. One of Abu Nuwas’s most famous compilations of poetry is known as Ghazal. In it, he celebrates his love for 15-year-old teenagers (khumasi), young men in military training or even those who have started growing facial hair (muaddir). In his “Love in Bloom,” Abu Nuwas describes his bond with a male lover as an “unbreakable rope.”

Many other excellent classical Muslim poets wrote in homoerotic tones, including the Persian Ibn Dawud (868-909), Andalusian Ibn Quzman (1080-1160), and the Arab Sicilian Ibn Hamdis (1053-1133). Lovemaking manuals are also to be found, such as The Perfumed Garden (Al-Rawd Al-Atir fi Nuzhat Al-Khatir) by the Tunisian Shaiykh Muhammad ibn Umar Al-Nafwazi, between 1410 and 1434, and The Book of Respective Merits of Maids and Young Men (Kitab Mafaharat Al-Jawari wa Al-Ghilman) by the prolific Al-Jahiz (777-869).

Later on still, Omar Khayyam (d. 1126) set the tone for sexuality in his Quartets (Ruba’iyyat), and Sa’di of Shiraz (1184-1291) graphically discusses his love of young men. Most famous of them all, Jalal Al-Din Rumi (1207-1273) passionately writes about his deep affection for the wandering mystic Shams Al-Din Tabriz, leading many modern academics to conclude that he must have been deeply in love with him.

But as prudish Victorian values spread from Europe to the Middle East through colonialism, and as 19th century neo-fundamentalist Wahhabism began to take hold in the Arabian peninsula, and as 20th century Islamism gained ground, spreading from Egypt around the globe, censorship, misogyny and homophobia began to spread among Muslims worldwide.

The best example of the way in which Muslim attitudes to sex have gone backwards is found in the Arabian fantasy A Thousand and One Nights. Keen to read a version of this masterpiece in its original Arabic, I once excitedly rushed to purchase a copy from an Egyptian bazaar. Imagine my disbelief when I came home to find “family version” stamped on the inside. The famed court of the late Abbasid Caliph Harun Al-Rashid, where this story was originally related, was able to tolerate the racier parts of this classic Arabic tale while parts of modern Egypt apparently could not.

Despite this diverse history, homosexuality is forbidden today in almost every modern Muslim-majority country, while censorship, homophobia, and misogyny reach worryingly high levels.

Previous Orientalist assumptions that fetishized Eastern sexuality have given way to a new form of generalization that accepts as normal the overbearing religious conservativism that has swept across Muslim-majority societies.

In response to this current climate of fear, and to the backdrop of ISIS thugs throwing gays off buildings in Syria, my organization Quilliam has commissioned an art exhibition at the Free Word Centre in order to throw open this debate by displaying some of the sexual diversity within past and contemporary Muslim tradition.

Curated by Harry Seymour and Rachel Maggart (full disclosure: we’re married) and named after the line from the Abu Nuwas poem, Unbreakable Rope is an artistic response to this rising neo-fundamentalist prejudice. The show will also involve a panel discussion this month featuring gay Muslims responding to the alarming rates of homophobia present within our communities.

For too long, populist demagogues, xenophobes and racists have been able to use coded language about intolerable Muslim intolerance to argue that Muslims have no place in Europe. We must begin to discuss these issues with courage and candour, rather than trying to pretend there is no problem, or shying away from the difficult conversation we all must have around the non-integration of Europe’s Muslims.

In this way, if we are able to bank the progress that has been made, admit to the progress that is yet to be made, and throw open the conversation for all to participate, perhaps, just perhaps, we will be able to pull the rug out from under the feet of populists who want us all to believe that the only good Muslim is a deported Muslim.

But the only way to achieve this is by owning the conversation, not fearing it, nor by ceding it to those who seek to use these depressing survey results for their altogether different aim.

Source: The Daily Beast

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
Related tags : Arab gaygayhomosexualityIslamLGBTMuslimMuslim gaywestWhy Does Gay Sex Scare Modern Muslims? It Didn’t in the Golden Age

Post navigation

Previous Article

Evolution of Turmoil in Middle East: Chemistry of Complex Dynamics (Part Three)

Next Article

Player’s Haircut Spots Saudi’s Existential Dilemmas

Related Articles

LGBT+Social Minorities
July 24, 20160259

Arab Queers Do Exist

Years ago, in one of the many social groups that coalesce around shared interests and social affiliations of LGBT people in Egypt, we used to gather at a friend's place and watch old shows of Sherih
Read More
Lebanese Security Forces Try to Close LGBT Conference LebanonLGBT+News
October 11, 20180142

Lebanese Security Forces Try to Close LGBT Conference

Lebanese General Security officers unlawfully attempted to shut down a conference on the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people on September 29, 2018, Human Rights Watch sai
Read More
Apostasy Isn't Punishable Says Morocco’s High Religious Committee Atheists+MoroccoReligion +Social Minorities
February 8, 20170131

Apostasy Isn’t Punishable Says Morocco’s High Religious Committee

Casablanca – Morocco’s High Religious  Committee has retracted its Islamic ruling stating that apostasy is punishable by death and has decided to permit Muslims to change their religion. The High R
Read More
Misr Al Qadima, Cairo, Egypt - © Photo: Hakim Khatib/MPC Journal AnalysisRadicalisationReligion +
January 23, 20170134

Controversy of Islamist Politics on Other Belief Systems

Terrorist attacks have been randomly sweeping the world. While uncertainty around bloody conflicts in West Asia and Africa, sectarian politics in Arabia and Iran, integration issues in Europe and No
Read More
Radicalisation between Prevention and Instrumentalisation of Religion - MPC Journal - Hakim Khatib Culture +RadicalisationReligion +
February 21, 20170161

Radicalisation between Prevention and Instrumentalisation of Religion

While forms of radicalisation have been on the rise worldwide, some young Muslims, especially in European prisons, seem to get caught up in religious fundamentalism, and increasingly become entangle
Read More
Atheists+Saudi ArabiaSocial Minorities
June 30, 20172539

Taboo of Atheism in Saudi Arabia

Atheism remains one of the most extreme taboos in Saudi Arabia. It is a red line that no one can cross. Atheists in Saudi Arabia have been suffering from imprisonment, maginalisation, slander, ostra
Read More
AnalysisReligion +
May 28, 20160128

Violence More Common in Bible Than Quran

"Violence more common" in Bible than Quran, text analysis reveals The Old Testament was found to be more than twice as violent as the Quran An analysis into whether the Quran is more violent t
Read More
A baby's bottle lies on the blood-stained floor of the Sufi shrine of Lal Shahbaz Qalandar in Sehwan, Sindh Province, on February 17, a day after a bomb killed at least 70 people, including children, at the shrine. Pakistan cracked down nationwide soon after the blast, claimed by the 'Islamic State of Iraq and Syria' (ISIS). [Asif Hassan/AFP] NewsReligion +
June 13, 20173188

Religious Scholars Declare Suicide Attacks Forbidden in Islam

Religious scholars from all schools of thought on Saturday issued a fatwa (religious decree) that declared suicide attacks, armed insurgency against a state and use of force in the name of imposing
Read More

Comments (1)

  1. Avatar
    xxx
    July 6, 2016 at 11:57 pm

    Εveryone loves ԝhat you guys tend to be up too.
    Such clever work and reporting! Keep up the fantastic
    ᴡorks guys.

Comment here Cancel reply

Subscribe to receive updates via email:

Most read Articles

Driving out Islamic State from Libya: What Lies Ahead?
Driving out Islamic State from Libya: What Lies Ahead?
October 2, 2016
How Fares Islamic State?
How Fares Islamic State?
December 25, 2015
The Changing Face of Islam in Kurdistan
The Changing Face of Islam in Kurdistan
March 15, 2016
The Kurds, Assad and the Shape of a Future Syria
The Kurds, Assad and the Shape of a Future Syria
October 20, 2019
Canadians Keep Asking Questions About Saudi Arms Deal
Canadians Keep Asking Questions About Saudi Arms Deal
April 10, 2016
Egypt’s President Asks Muslims to Mind What They Are Doing to Humanity
Egypt’s President Asks Muslims to Mind What They Are Doing to Humanity
March 25, 2015
Hamas, Fatah and Israel – An Eternal Triangle
Hamas, Fatah and Israel – An Eternal Triangle
October 16, 2018
GAY Rights Surface As Lebanon Prepares for Election
GAY Rights Surface As Lebanon Prepares for Election
May 8, 2018
France: The New Leader of the Free World?
France: The New Leader of the Free World?
December 7, 2015
Several People Arrested in Kuwait for Having Links to Iran and Hizbollah
Several People Arrested in Kuwait for Having Links to Iran and Hizbollah
September 2, 2015

MPC Journal’s Archive

Why Does Gay Sex Scare Modern Muslims? It Didn’t in the Golden Age
© Mashreq Politics & Culture Journal 2014 – 2019. All rights reserved.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.